The other day I found some notes on incoming resumes. In this particular instance, I was sifting resumes to hire a part-time in-house designer and office administrator (yes, it was two jobs in one.)
My notes were personal and determined whether or not the incoming resumes got a checkmark (meaning let’s call them back and set up an interview!) or got filed in the round file cabinet (meaning the bin.)
Here’s some highlights:
“Personal website is pretty awful”
“Leaving for France in April? WTF?”
“1000% OVERQUALIFIED”
“No office experience. Nice typography though.”
“Lists ‘Windows’ twice under ‘Software’, probably not good at computers”
“DOESN’T EVEN LIVE IN VANCOUVER”
“Website portfolio pisses me off” (in this instance I think they had some Flash template site)
As you can see, I’m a bit difficult to please.
This hiring process took place about a year ago, at the peak of the recession when unemployment was rampant and people were desperate for jobs. I’d sifted over a hundred resumes before selecting callbacks.
I definitely noticed a lot of repeat offenses; things people did when they applied that immediately annoyed me or put their resume in the round file cabinet. I’m going to share these things.
ATTN: PEOPLE OF CRAIGSLIST: STOP DOING THESE THINGS WHEN JOB HUNTING!:
Don’t bother reading the job description before applying: One of the resumes arrived with a nicely formatted cover letter… stating the applicant is great with accounting/bookkeeping and looks forward to saving our firm money. Did they even READ the job description before they applied?? A cover letter that isn’t relevant is far worse than none at all.
Poor grammar and spelling: I got so many resumes with typos and horrible grammar it made me want to cry. Nearly all the cover letters and emails had at least one glaringly obvious grammatical error or horrible spelling, but when it’s on the actual resume, it’s just inexcusable.
Send a 1 paragraph bulleted resume in 8 pt type. The print designers who applied were by far the worst for this. I got resumes with nothing more than a name, email address, website for portfolio samples, and the work history was nothing more than a bulleted list of company names and dates. How can we hire you if we barely know anything about you?
Apply for stuff there’s no way you’re qualified for. Kudos to you for being confident, but either you didn’t read the job description or you have an inflated sense of self-worth. Sadly, you’re wasting everyone’s time.
Send a presumptuous cover letter. I got a cover letter with salary expectations of $35K. This was for a 2 day a week part time position. Either we got a generic template cover letter (again, worse than none at all, please expend some effort writing about the job you’re applying for!) or you didn’t read the job posting at all!
The overall experience has led me to believe Craigslist is a bad place to look for a new hire. While it does get a lot of eyes, it also produces a lot of junk results, which someone then has to sift through.
At least in this case, the sifting process gave me some insight and fodder for a blog post!






